Bottled Water: Did the water
in the bottle you just purchased really come from the beautiful spring shown on
the label? How can you be sure the water in the bottle is any cleaner or safer
than your tap water? How does the cost, both short term and long term, compare
with other water purification options?
Bottled water is simply water from some source
that a company (or in the case of water vending machines, the consumer)
has placed in a bottle for resale. Bottled water can have minimal
(or no) processing - as in natural spring or mineral water, or it can be
completely filtered and demineralized to nearly pure water and then have
minerals added back in to make it taste better.
But, how can you be sure the water
in the bottle you
purchased is any cleaner or safer than your tap water?
Just
like with any of
the other water treatment solutions, you will
find reputable companies that
provide a safe, quality
product, and you will find companies that fill their
bottles
using the local, municipal water. Each company must be
evaluated individually (A
Review of Bottled Water and a
NRDC
Discussion of Bottled Water). There are 2 regulatory
organizations, 1 trade association, and 1
independent
certification organization which contribute to
insuring the
safety and quality of bottled water.
According to the University of
Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, College of Agriculture, Cooperative Extension
Service, bottled water is regulated at the federal level, and in some cases, at
the state level. Bottled water suppliers who are members of the International
Bottled Water Association (IBWA) regulate themselves and are given unannounced
inspections by NSF International. Bottled water companies can also
have their product certified by NSF International.
Federal standards - Bottled water is
regulated by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), which requires
manufacturers to submit samples regularly for testing. In the United States, the
concentration of contaminants found in bottled water must be less than the
"allowable levels" set by the FDA which are essentially the same as the maximum
contaminant levels that the EPA requires municipal water supplies to meet.
State standards - Individual states must enforce the federal bottled
water regulations, but they can also pass stricter standards.
International Bottled Water
Association. The bottled water industry regulates itself through the
International Bottled Water Association (IBWA). Bottled water FAQs. The
IBWA sets manufacturing requirements, which help to ensure that bottlers meet
FDA health standards. Bottled water producers who are members of IBWA are
inspected annually by an independent laboratory, the National Sanitation
Foundation. Through unannounced inspections, members are evaluated on compliance
with the IBWA's performance requirements and FDA Quality Standards. Not all
bottled water manufacturers are members of the IBWA. Of the 475 bottling plants
in the United States (in 1994), 250 are members. The label may indicate whether
a bottled water comes from a member company.
You might want to check NSF
International to see if the bottled water you are interested in
purchasing is certified. The NSF Bottled Water Certification Program is an annual, voluntary certification process that includes both extensive product evaluations as well as on-site audits of bottling facilities.
The NSF testing program provides for annual unannounced plant inspections covering every aspect of a bottler's operation, from the source of the water, through the disinfection and treatment process, and including the container closure process.
The company also performs extensive product testing for over 160 chemical, inorganic, radiological, and microbiological contaminants.
An interesting article from Scientific American magazine on bottled
water.
The advantages of Bottled Water include:
An
emergency source of water in the event your primary
water source fails or becomes contaminated.
A
convenient source of usually safe water for drinking
outside of the home.
Bottled
water, since it does not contain chlorine, and may
contain a mix of minerals to enhance flavor, may taste
better
than untreated tap water.
The bottled water industry would like the public to believe that
bottled water is purer and safer than tap water and
water
produced by other treatment methods. The actual
quality of
bottled water depends on the bottling company, and
most is
probably of good quality.
High quality home water treatment
methods (filtration, reverse
osmosis, and distillation) can
usually produce water of equal
or better quality, however.
The disadvantages of Bottled Water include:
Cost - Bottled water costs anywhere from
$0.25 a gallon for
water from a vending machine to $0.50 for generic water
jugs you purchase in a store to $1.00 -
$1.50 or more for
water delivered to your home.
If you purchase 10 gallons of
bottled water a week, you will
spend $260 (at $.50/gal), $520 (at $1.00/gal),
$780 (at
$1.50/gal), or more every year. Many of us are willing to
pay extraordinary prices for the
availability and convenience of of certain
products. That 16
ounce bottle of "designer water" you just purchased at the
gas
station for $0.69 costs $5.52 per gallon, probably more
than twice as much per gallon as your gas!
Purchasing one
16 oz bottle per day (at $0.69 per bottle) will cost you $248
per
year - that's for a total of 45 gallons. If you take a minute
to fill your own well-cleaned bottle with filtered or
distilled
water, however, a 16 oz bottle of water would
cost perhaps
1 - 2 cents a day, or less than $7.30 per year.
Convenience - Using
bottled water requires moving and
storing jugs or bottles of water. Water weighs
about eight
pounds per gallon, or about 40 pounds per five gallon bottle.
Failure of a small valve can lead to a big mess, as I
discovered after arriving
home one evening after a long day
at work to find 3 gallons of water soaking into the
rug.
Environmental Impact -
Producing bottles uses resources,
and unless they are reused or recycled, they
cause a waste
disposal problem. Recycle or reuse the empty bottles, if at all
possible.
Keep it Clean - According to the University of
Illinois at
Urbana-Champaign, College of Agriculture, Cooperative
Extension
Service, "If you choose bottled water after careful investigation, keep
in
mind that all of your hard work will go to waste if you
aren't careful about
keeping your bottled water clean. You
have to be faithful in maintaining the
hygiene of your
bottled water, or you may increase your exposure to
bacteria.
Bacteria grow best in warm, moist areas. The wet,
warm, threaded cap of an
unrefrigerated bottle of water is a
perfect place for bacteria to grow; they
will begin to grow as
soon as you break the seal. If ingested, these bacteria
can
cause gastrointestinal problems and other health risks. The
key is to
maintain the cleanliness of your bottles and store
them properly. Follow these
hints:
1) Store the bottle in a refrigerator at a temperature above
freezing but
less than 50 degrees Fahrenheit.
2) Wipe the seal with a clean cloth after each
use.
3) Avoid any type of buildup in the bottle cap.
4) If your bottle is
refillable, make sure it is well-cleaned and
rinsed before refilling. If
possible, recycle the old bottle
and obtain a fresh, sterile, sealed bottle."
5 gallon water dispensers
must also be kept meticulously
clean to prevent bacteria from growing in the
reservoir area
and bubbling into the bottle. Safety & Health Services
cleaning
recommendations. (pdf file)
|