Risk Factors for Water Contaminants
What Conditions Increase the Risk of Having Certain Water Contaminants?
The information on this page is particularly important if you have young children, or if you
or a member of your family is pregnant or has a compromised immune system.

 


Introduction

Concerns about
   
water safety
Children and
    contaminated
    water
Pregnancy and
    drinking water
    contaminants


Introduction
Materials
    dissolved in
    water
    - Inorganics
    - Organics

Materials
    suspended in
    water
    - Pathogens
    - Asbestos
Interview

    excerpt

 
Drinking water 
    sources

Municipal
    providers
Private wells
Location of
    home
Chlorination
    and DBPs
High risk

    populations
Home age & lead
Use Sensory

    clues to identify   
    contaminants   


Importance of
    product
    certification

Things to consider
Water treatment
    methods, POU
    - Boiling
    - Distillation
    - Reverse
     Osmosis (RO)   
    - Filtration
        * Sediment
        * Activated
          carbon
             GAC
             Solid block
        * Pore size
    - Bottled water
    - Ultraviolet (UV)
    - Water softeners
    - KDF
    - Ion exchange
Comparison of
    drinking water
    treatment methods
Comparison of

    long-term costs
    for water
    treatment

Comparison of long-term costs of water treatment Emergency

    Water Treatment 

Four Steps to
    determining the
    best water
    treatment method
    (new 2/05)

Recommendations
Questions
Comments and
    suggestions
Refer this site
    to friends
About Me


Over 300 links to
    drinking water
    related sites

Terrorism and
    Drinking Water
   
(updated 1/1/05)

bullet Source of Your Drinking Water
   Municipal water provider
   Private water supply  
  
(well, spring, surface water)

bullet Where You Live
   Industrial area
   Agricultural area

bullet Chlorinated Water and the Risk of Disinfection Byproducts

bullet Populations at Risk from Water Contaminants
   Pregnancy
   Young children
   Elderly and immunocompromised

bullet Home Age and the Risk of Lead Contamination

bullet Water Problem Table - Use sensory clues to identify common water problems

bullet Table of Contaminants and Treatment Methods

bullet A Four-Step Guide - Information on selecting a water treatment method for your specific situation.

Drinking Water Sources:

 

The geographic region where people live is an important contributing factor to both the quality and availability of fresh water.  You might be interested in viewing Globalis, a fascinating interactive world map on the web which highlights the similarities and differences between the countries of this world and, in addition to many other comparisons, provides a map  of water quality in different regions of the world (on the left select Category 'Water' and the indicator, 'Access to safe water' - the map can be zoomed to region and the 'show ranking' option lists countries by access to safe water).  Another interesting article from The Why Files takes a look at water availability in different regions of the world.  Every one who is able to turn on a faucet and expect to fill their glass with clean, safe water should visit the Peace Corps' Water in Africa site.

 
Detour to a brief discussion about fresh water abundance, surface water, and ground water.

 If you are provided with municipal water, the responsibility for your safe drinking water lies with the water provider.  

bullet Although water companies in the US and many other countries are strictly regulated and the treated water must meet certain minimum purity and safety standards, all water companies are not created equal.  You can reasonably assume that most are doing the best they can with the resources available to them - if for no other reason than to keep their name out of the evening news.
bullet In general, though, the larger water companies (in the US anyway) have greater resources available to treat and distribute the water and maintain the distribution infrastructure.  And, because they serve more people, they are required to meet stricter regulations.

 

Do you receive and read water quality reports sent out by your water provider?

bullet

The EPA has a site, Water Where You Live, that enables you to obtain information about specific water treatment companies in the U.S.  After you click on your state, click on the "Drinking Water" link about 5 down from the top.  If your water company has an on-line quality report, you can read it.  You can also locate information about water companies by county.

bullet

The Safe Drinking Water Act of 1996 mandated that public water companies were to prepare annual water quality reports and make them available to all customers.

bullet

The Campaign for Safe and Affordable Drinking Water (CSADW) maintains a site that describes water quality reports and discusses how to interpret them.  The National Environmental Education & Training Foundation (NEETF) also maintains a site that describes how to interpret water quality reports.  A PDF file, Drinking Water Quality Reports also has valuable information. 


 Some information for well owners or people who use surface water for drinking.  People with private water supplies are responsible for the safety of their own drinking water.  While all wells, springs, and surface water should be tested regularly, there are some situations where it is critical to know what is in your water:

bullet If you use surface water or water from an unconfined aquifer and have any sources of pollution nearby, you are at risk for contaminated water. 
bullet If you or members of your family are at higher risk of health problems from contaminants, you should know what is in your water.
bullet If the quality of your water suddenly changes - new taste

The depth of a well is not usually as important as the type of aquifer from which the well draws.  In general, well water from an unconfined aquifer is much more prone to contamination than water from a confined aquifer.  Click here to learn more about aquifers and the contaminant risks associated with each type.  For the teachers who are visiting: I discovered what appears to be a very interesting  groundwater model that demonstrates confined and unconfined aquifers, how water and contaminants move through aquifers, various soil structures, and watersheds.


Poorly designed or maintained septic systems are a potential source of contamination for wells or springs mostly in unconfined aquifers.  The most common contaminants from septic systems tend to be E. coli and nitrates, but if other chemicals are flushed into the septic system by you or your neighbors, they can become part of the ground or surface water pollutants as well.

The site, Well Water & Drinking Water Help Links, contains a number of links to other sites with information for the well owner.

Water Testing:
If you use municipal water you should be able to obtain a water quality report yearly and, except for special circumstances, would probably not need to test your water.  If you use well, spring, or surface water, it is important to test your water periodically  for contaminants liable to be present in your water.  As discussed above, water quality from a water source can change over time - particularly in surface water or shallow, unconfined aquifers.  The University of Tennessee Agricultural Extension Service article, Safety of Private Water Supplies, has important suggestions and information about testing for the safety of your well water.

Where You Live:

Home Located in an Industrial Area:  
The range of possible industrial pollutants is extremely large. Important contaminants include heavy metals and many thousands of kinds of manufactured chemicals.  Water contamination can occur from:
Emissions into the atmosphere that either settle onto or wash onto the earth's surface and from there into the surface or ground water.
Waste dumps that leak into surface or ground water.
Leakage from storage areas of chemical products or their precursors.
Accidents and spills during transport of chemicals.
Direct dumping of contaminants into surface water for disposal.

A recent movie that examines some consequences of industrial pollution is A Civil Action starring John Travolta.

Home Located in an Agricultural Area:
Farms can have many potential sources of pollution for the underlying water, including: manure lagoon, feedlot / barn, septic system, earthen silage pit, fuel storage tank, chemical storage area, chemical mixing area, dump or landfill, and fields on which fertilizers or pesticides have been applied.  For more information on farm wells, go to: Well Water Location & Condition on the Farm.   In addition to the health effects of nitrates on children, discussed above, nitrates in drinking water have also been associated with  an increased risk for Non-Hodgkin lymphoma

Chlorinated Water and the Risk of Disinfection Byproducts:

Is your water Chlorinated?
bullet Most municipal water treatment plants use chlorine to disinfect the water before it leaves the treatment plant and/or keep the water biologically safe during the distribution process.  Many well users also use chlorine to disinfect their water.

bullet Chlorine, while an excellent disinfectant, reacts with organic material in the source water to produce a group of chlorinated organic compounds collectively known as Disinfection Byproduct (DBPs).  According to several EPA articles

"While disinfectants are effective in controlling many microorganisms, they react with natural organic and inorganic matter in source water and distribution systems to form DBPs. Results from toxicology studies have shown several DBPs to be carcinogenic in laboratory animals. Other DBPs have also been shown to cause adverse reproductive or developmental effects in laboratory animals. Several epidemiology studies have suggested a weak association between certain cancers (e.g., bladder) or reproductive and developmental effects, and exposure to chlorinated surface water. More than 200 million people consume water that has been disinfected. Because of the large population exposed, health risks associated with DBPs, even if small, need to be taken seriously."

In general, the levels of DBPs are highest in treated water from sources with high organic matter content, such as rivers and lakes, and lowest when the source is groundwater. Within a single water supply, however, DBP levels can vary greatly, depending on both water quality and treatment conditions (this is an informative article on Chlorinated Disinfection By-Products).
The DBPs include Total Trihalomethanes (TTHMs) (including chloroform, bromodichloromethane, dibromochloromethane, and bromoform),  and Haloacetic Acids (HAAs) (dichloroacetic acid and trichloroacetic acid)

 

In 1979, the EPA set an interim Maximum Contaminant Level (MCL) for TTHMs of 0.10 mg/l (or 100 microgram/l) as an annual average. This applies to any community water system serving at least 10,000 people that adds a disinfectant to the drinking water during any part of the treatment process.  By 2002 the MCL for TTHMS will be lowered to 0.08mg/l (or  80 ug/l) and a MCL for HAAs will be set at 0.06mg/l

 

bullet

The quote from the EPA above tells only part of the story.  In addition to laboratory studies showing cancers and reproductive problems in animals, there is a growing body of evidence based on epidemiological studies that implicates DBPs as contributing to problems during pregnancy (discussed below).

bullet

There is also epidemiological evidence suggesting a weak association between the consumption of chlorinated drinking water and the occurrence of bladder, colon, and rectal cancer (and possibly even some brain cancers).  

bullet

In epidemiological studies, investigators compare health effects in a population of people who drink water containing higher levels of DBS with a similar group of people who drink water with lower levels of DPS.  According to some estimates, anywhere between two and seventeen percent of all bladder cancer cases in the U.S. may be due to DBPs.   It is a tough balancing act between adding too little chlorine (resulting in more microbial contaminants and fewer DBPs), and too much chlorine (resulting in dead microbes and higher levels of DBPs).

bullet

A 1996 study by King and Marrett concluded "that the risk of bladder cancer increases with both duration and concentration of exposure to chlorination by-products".  They found that those exposed to chlorinated surface water for 35 or more years had a 1.4 times increased risk of bladder cancer compared with those exposed for less than 10 years, and those exposed to an estimated THM level greater than 49 micrograms/liter for 35 or more years had 1.63 times the risk of those exposed for less than 10 years.

Populations At Greater Risk from Water Contaminants:
        Pregnant Women, Children, Elderly, Immunocompromised

Any person who requires water of a specific microbiological purity should follow the advice of their doctor or local health officials regarding the use and consumption of tap water treated by ANY purification system.

Home Age and the Risk of Lead Contamination:

The age of your home can be an important indicator of
  whether lead might be a contaminant in your drinking water.
  
Lead is a serious threat to human health and can adversely affect almost every
    organ in the human body. 

Lead contamination usually occurs in the home as water dissolves lead from
    household plumbing made with lead containing materials.  Even many "lead-free
    fixtures still contain some lead.
More likely than not, water in buildings less than five years old or that were built
    before about 1987 have some levels of lead contamination (In the US, anyway - I
    suspect risks are similar in other countries, but check).   

Boiling the water will not reduce the amount of lead.
Young children and pregnant women have the greatest risk from even short term
    lead exposure.

An adequate calcium intake can help protect against lead poisoning - but that is
    NOT a substitute for lead reducing methods discussed below.

 

Indicators for high lead content in your drinking water
    Lead levels in your drinking water are likely to be highest if:

     your home has faucets or fittings of brass which contains some lead, or
     your home or water system has lead pipes, or
     your home has copper pipes with lead solder, and
         the house is less than five years old, or
         you have naturally soft water, or 
         your water is acidic, (pH below 7), or
        
water often sits in the pipes for several hours, or
         you use hot water from the tap to make formula or drinks
        
you regularly notice blue/green stains on sinks, tubs, and fixtures (this
              is probably copper, but it is an indication of corrosive water which will
              also dissolve lead).

 

Check for lead water pipes
    
Inside your home - Locate the pipe leading to the kitchen tap, and follow it
         as far as possible until it exits your home
.  Unpainted lead pipes are dull
         gray and soft.  If you scrape the surface gently with a knife, you will see
        
the shiny, silver-colored metal beneath.
     If possible, the supply line from the water main to your home - Try to find
          a place where the supply line is accessible (water meter for example) and
          check for indications of lead pipe.
     Other types of pipe in use
         Copper - bright copper-brown color may have silver colored metal around
             the soldered joints - the solder may contain lead.
         Iron/Steel - black, may be rusty, and is quite hard. The pipe may have a
             shinny galvanized coating.
         Plastic - may be white, blue, gray, black, etc. Lead compounds may
             also be present in some plastic plumbing components.  Lead may be
             used in the manufacture of the plastic plumbing products as a
             plasticizer. Plastic plumbing components that are certified by the NSF
             International do not contain lead. Plastic materials certified by NSF are
             recommended for potable water plumbing applications.
Plumbing components made of bronze and brass contain 3% to 8% lead.
Ace Hardware Guide to Water Pipes

 

If your drinking water has not been tested for lead, or if it does
    contain lead, seriously consider taking the following precautions.

bullet Install one of the several treatment methods that are effective at removing lead. 
bullet If the water has not been used in a particular faucet for six hours or longer, run the cold water tap until the water is noticeably colder, about a minute, to "flush" the pipes.
bullet Use only cold water from the tap for drinking, cooking, and especially making baby formula. Hot water dissolves materials better than cold water and thus may contain higher levels of lead.
bullet Frequently clean the screens and aerators in faucets to remove captured lead particles.
bullet If building or remodeling, only use "lead free" piping and materials for plumbing.  Still, as noted above, even "lead free" brass fixtures probably have traces of lead in them.
bullet If you are served by a public water system contact your supplier and ask whether or not the supply system contains lead piping, and whether your water is corrosive. If either answer is yes, ask what steps the supplier is taking to deal with the problem of lead contamination.
One indication that your water is corrosive (if you have copper
    pipes) is that you may notice
blue/green stains in tubs, sinks, and
    around faucets.  If your water is dissolving copper, and if there is
    lead in the pipes, solder, or fixtures, there is a good chance your
    water is also dissolving lead!

Click here to view more information about lead contamination in
    drinking water.

Note: Drinking water is estimated to contribute only 10 to 20 percent of the total lead exposure in young children. Make certain you are informed about all of the risks for lead exposure.  You can obtain more information about lead exposure from drinking water or other sources at this EPA document Lead In Your Home: Parent's Reference Guide is a comprehensive, 67 page EPA document (in PDF format) for parents who already know their children are at risk of lead exposure.

Contaminants and Sensory Clues:

Great looking, smelling, and tasting water is no guarantee that you have
      safe water!

      Many contaminants, lead, mercury, E. coli, disinfection byproducts - in fact
          the majority of the harmful contaminants listed below - have no taste
          or smell, nor would they be visible in harmful quantities. 

Click here to view more information about water safety and well testing.


If your water normally looks, tastes, and smells good and then suddenly becomes cloudy (turbid) or acquires a bad smell or taste it may be an indicator that the purification process has failed.  Immediately begin using water filtered with a high quality filter, bottled water, or otherwise purified water until you have determined that your water is safe.  That would also be a very good time to consider looking for a permanent water treatment solution.

Water Problem Table
Identify Common Water Contaminants by Their Sensory Clues

Important Introduction

Color
Blue to Blue-green
Cloudy, or Milky
Reddish - orange
Dark brown to Black
Yellow

Deposits, Spots, & Sediment
Soap scum 
Bathtub rings
Scaly, whitish
   deposit
Spots on clothing
Spots on dishes
Spotting, mottling,  of
   teeth
Red - brown slime
Black - brown slime
Reddish - brown
   sediment
Grittiness,
   abrasiveness
Staining
Blue-green stains
Brown-red stains
Black stains
Blackening and
   pitting of metal
   sinks and fixtures
Gray stains
Yellow stains


Taste
Alkaline
Metallic
Salty, brackish
Sharp chemical Alkaline
Metallic
Salty, brackish
Sharp chemical
Odor
Chlorine
Detergent
Sweet, perfume
Fishy
Rotten eggs
Oil or gas
Sewage
Musty, earthy

 

The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has several excellent sites that describe water contaminants.  The  EPA's Drinking Water Standards site gives you a list of the regulated contaminants, their maximum allowable contaminant levels, the main source(s) of the contaminants, and their health effects.  A more comprehensive EPA site is, What are the health effects of contaminants in drinking water?  
Another excellent site for learning about the health effects of water contaminants is The National Environmental Education & Training Foundation (NEETF) site, 40 Fact Sheets for Common Drinking Water Contaminants.  


Have you ever been told that your household water is unsafe and to either boil your water before drinking it or to drink bottled water until the problem has been corrected?


Have you or a member of your family ever become ill from your home drinking water?

If you answer "yes" to either question, it would probably be a good idea to invest in a high quality water treatment system.  According to the National Primary Drinking Water Regulations: Public Notification Rule; Final Rule, Section 1414(c)(2)(C), The EPA regulations "require Public Water Services to distribute a notice within 24 hours to persons served for violations with potential to have serious adverse effects on human health from short-term exposure".  Considerable exposure to the contaminant can occur during that period.

Table of Contaminants and Treatment Methods

Comparison of Drinking Water Treatment Methods

I developed a Comparison Table listing different drinking water treatment technologies and the contaminants they remove to make it easier for you to determine which process, or combination of processes will be best for your particular drinking water situation.
If this table is too large for your screen, I have
    broken it into two separate tables, one
    covering the biological and organic
    contaminants, and the other covering the
    inorganic contaminants.  They should be
    easier to read on monitors set at 800 X 600.

I also developed another table that shows similar water treatment information in a somewhat different format that you might want to take a look at.  This table is geared mostly to point of use water treatment methods.

The Water Quality Association (WQA) also has a Table of Water Contaminants, their health effects, and removal methods

Please be advised that the information on this page and on this site is for general educational information only and is NOT intended to make any specific health claims or recommend any specific treatment method or preventative advice for any health issue or problem.  Consult your physician or a health specialist for specific steps to take for your specific health requirements!

 



Safe Surf IconRSAC Icon

Copyright © 2005 Randy Johnson. All rights reserved.